Office opening hours: 8.30am to 5.30pm Monday to Friday. Offices closed on Bank Holidays.
Home Menu Search

Police Requests

Police Requests for Medical Records

Statutory responsibility vs professional obligations - a personal view

I am proud to be a GP and have enjoyed being part of a respected profession for over 30 years. General Practice has never been "just a job" and has always been a vocation and a profession. Being part of the community and working as a family doctor makes us unique, call me old fashioned but I still consider that it is an honor and a privilege to be a GP.

Over the last few years we have all found that our working lives have got busier and the demands on us have increased significantly. This is not only in terms of clinical time but the administrative burden has become, at times, unmanageable. I therefore support the BMA’s work to try and help resolve the unnecessary additional workload for GPs.

You will have seen the recent BMA advice on requests for information about patients from the Police.(https://www.bma.org.uk/advice/employment/fees/medical-records)

The Police can always request information from a Practice with the patient’s consent. However, there is also a public interest test and you are permitted to release information without consent in certain circumstance. This could be to prevent a serious crime (a public interest test) or it may be authorised via the use of a Data Protection Form, which needs to be signed by a Senior Police Officer.

You should only give the minimum, or relevant, information, to satisfy the request: there is a difference between disclosing general information about a patient, and releasing copies of a patient’s medical record. The golden rule is for both the Practice and the Police to be able to justify the release of information being in the public interest.

In the past the advice was that Practices could not charge for the release of this information as Practices saw this as part of their professional duty and it would need to be an Inspector or above who had to sign a Data Protection Form

The recent BMA advice has taken a new interpretation on the law that relates to the release of patient information and has suggested that practices can charge a fee for this information. This has already caused significant problems for the Police forces locally and hence in Hampshire all Practices have received a letter from the Police about this.

So where does this leave us?

I go back to the start of this topic. I may not have a statutory responsibility to provide information to the Police, in the public interest, without charging them a fee but my feelings of professional duty tells me that I should continue to work as before and provide this information without charge and accept the Data Protection Form with an Inspector's signature. In return, I would expect to continue the positive and professional relationship that I have with the Police locally.

Each situation needs to be examined carefully and the balance struck between the two. Each of us must be prepared to justify our actions either to the Information Commissioner's Office, if release of information was later deemed a data protection breach but also to our patients and the public if any harm resulted from us withholding information from the Police in the vital work that they do. It is sometimes a difficult judgment but one that, as professionals, we must be prepared to make.

My advice is to continue with the previous BMA position and release information with a signed Data Protection Form without charge. However practices are of course free to choose to follow the updated BMA advice regarding charging if they wish to do so.

Dr Nigel Watson, CEO Wessex LMCs

 

Related guidance...

Pro forma response to Police for practice - November 2017

Data Protection Act & Access to Notes / Medical Records

The Data Protection Act 1998. . . gives rights for living individuals to access their records. This right can also be exercised by...

Providing patient information to the Police

Email to all GPs, Practice Managers and CCGs Following my recent email update in which I included a section on our statutory...

LMC Update Sept 2017

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, on Sunday, 15th Sep 2017 I am sorry that this is another long email but there seems to be so much going...

Confidentiality after Death

Access to Deceased Patients' Health Records Note: the duty of confidentiality continues beyond death. The Access to Health Records Act...

LMC Update June 2017 - part 2

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, Normally at this time of year the focus for the LMC moves from new contract changes, year end problems,...

Firearms Licensing Process

Background: From 1 April 2016 new information sharing processes between GPs and the police were introduced in an attempt to ensure...

Practice Manager Newsletter October 2016

Email sent by Wessex LMCs This is the third in the series of our email newsletters for 2016, which we hope will be helpful - as ever,...

Related guidance...

Data Protection Act & Access to Notes / Medical Records

The Data Protection Act 1998. . . gives rights for living individuals to access their records. This right can also be exercised by an...

Providing patient information to the Police

Email to all GPs, Practice Managers and CCGs Following my recent email update in which I included a section on our statutory...

Confidentiality after Death

Access to Deceased Patients' Health Records Note: the duty of confidentiality continues beyond death. The Access to Health Records Act...

LMC Update June 2017 - part 2

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, Normally at this time of year the focus for the LMC moves from new contract changes, year end problems,...

LMC Update Sept 2017

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, on Sunday, 15th Sep 2017 I am sorry that this is another long email but there seems to be so much going...

Patients Accessing their Own Notes

Patients Requesting Access to their own Health Records When should access be given? There is nothing in the law that prevents health...

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, on Tuesday, 10 May 2016

Email sent by Wessex LMCs, on Tuesday, 10 May 2016 Over the last week there are two very important issues that have been raised...

This page appears in...

Download and bookmark...

About this page...

Updated on 20 November 2017 223 views